✨ Join Our HOMEBAKERS Club
Subscribe for exclusive recipes and cooking tips delivered to your inbox.
Available in 6-count or 12-count trays
Mix Flavors or all 1 flavor
5-7oz each (BIG Girls)
Our Gourmet Cookie Tray is loaded with thick, bakery-style cookies crafted to impress. Each cookie is rich, indulgent, and packed with premium fillings, gooey centers, and unforgettable flavors. Perfect for parties, gifting, holidays, dessert tables, or treating yourself to something truly extraordinary.
Your tray can include any of the following gourmet creations:
• Stuffed Chocolate Chip Nutella – A classic chocolate chip cookie with a warm gooey Nutella center.
• Brown Butter Chocolate Chip – Deep, rich, nutty brown-butter flavor with melty chocolate throughout.
• Reese’s Stuffed Chocolate Chip – Packed with peanut butter cups AND stuffed for that perfect chocolate-PB combo.
• S’mores Stuffed Cookie – Chocolate, marshmallow, and graham — the whole campfire experience inside a cookie.
• Brownie-Stuffed Nutella Cookie – A fudgy brownie hidden inside a Nutella-filled chocolate chip cookie.
• Lemon Stuffed Strawberry Pop-Tart – Bright lemon cookie with a sweet strawberry Pop-Tart surprise.
• Cranberry Orange – Soft, citrusy, and studded with tart cranberries — perfect year-round.
• Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Stuffed with Ganache – Chewy oatmeal cookie wrapped around rich chocolate filling.
• Christmas M&M Sugar Cookie (seasonal) – Festive, colorful, soft, and loaded with holiday cheer.
• Peanut Butter Stuffed Cookies – Soft peanut butter cookie with a creamy PB center.
• Strawberry Cream Cheese Cookies – Sweet strawberry cookie with a silky cream cheese center.
• Holiday gatherings
• Family celebrations
• Office treats
• Dessert tables
• Gifting
• Or as a “one for now, one for later” treat
Choose your tray size, choose your flavors, and enjoy a gourmet cookie experience unlike anything you’ll find in stores.